• 8AM.MEDIA
  • ویب‌سایت فارسی
  • پښتو ویب‌پاڼه
  • اۉزبېکچه ویب‌سایت
  • Podcast
Saturday, November 14, 2026
Hasht-e Subh
  • Home
  • News
    • Afghanistan News
    • World News
  • Opinion
    • Editorial
    • Analysis
  • Reports
    • Daily Reports
    • Investigative Reports
  • Society
    • The story of people
  • Women’s Word
  • Columns
    • Three Years After Afghanistan’s Fall: The Taliban’s Resurgence
    • Towards Equality
    • The Resurgence of the Taliban: Two Years Since Afghanistan’s Fall
    • Hebatullah Report Special Edition
    • Resistance for Education Special Edition
    • Special Column on Taliban’s Education Curriculum
    • Nawroz
  • Interviews
  • Contact Us
    • About Us
    • 8AM MEDIA Annual Awards
    • Submit an Article to Hasht-e-Subh
  • 8am.mediaBack
Subscribe
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
    • Afghanistan News
    • World News
  • Opinion
    • Editorial
    • Analysis
  • Reports
    • Daily Reports
    • Investigative Reports
  • Society
    • The story of people
  • Women’s Word
  • Columns
    • Three Years After Afghanistan’s Fall: The Taliban’s Resurgence
    • Towards Equality
    • The Resurgence of the Taliban: Two Years Since Afghanistan’s Fall
    • Hebatullah Report Special Edition
    • Resistance for Education Special Edition
    • Special Column on Taliban’s Education Curriculum
    • Nawroz
  • Interviews
  • Contact Us
    • About Us
    • 8AM MEDIA Annual Awards
    • Submit an Article to Hasht-e-Subh
  • 8am.mediaBack
No Result
View All Result
Hasht-e Subh
No Result
View All Result

Gaza War: What’s the Dispute Between the Prime Minister and Defense Minister About?

By: Shujauddin Amini

By: Shujauddin Amini By: Shujauddin Amini
21 May 2024 - Solar Hijri Date: 1403/03/01 [t_time:1716316129]
Gaza War: What’s the Dispute Between the Prime Minister and Defense Minister About?

Reuters

Recently, a seemingly serious dispute has arisen between Benjamin Netanyahu, the Prime Minister of Israel, and Yoav Gallant, the Defense Minister of this country, regarding the management of Gaza after the war. On Wednesday, May 15th, Gallant, in a live-covered press conference, criticized Netanyahu’s lack of attention to a clear plan regarding how to manage Gaza, stating, “I am opposed to political management and the establishment of a military government by Israel in this strip.” He added that his demand for establishing a governmental entity to replace Hamas has not received a clear response from the Prime Minister. Gallant stated that his country must find a non-military replacement for Hamas in Gaza, provided it does not pose a threat to Israelis.

It wasn’t long before Netanyahu responded to his minister explicitly, stating, “I am not willing to replace Fatahistan with Hamasistan.” Netanyahu added that the destruction of Hamas is the primary condition, and until this goal is achieved, discussing how to manage Gaza is meaningless. Netanyahu’s goal with “Fatahistan” is the Fatah movement led by Mahmoud Abbas, which governs the West Bank. He said that Fatah did not condemn the October 7th attack and that 80 percent of the residents of the West Bank welcomed it. Without naming Gallant, he also said, “This retired general makes excuses after eight months of inability to defeat Hamas.” A difference of opinion between the Prime Minister and the Defense Minister had emerged some time ago. After Netanyahu claimed in early April that the timing of the attack on Rafah had been determined, Gallant rejected his claim in contact with Lloyd Austin, the US Secretary of Defense.

Regarding the dispute between the Prime Minister and the Minister, several important points merit attention:

1- Netanyahu’s objective, along with his allied right-wing parties, was to turn Gaza into an uninhabitable area, but this goal was not achieved. For this reason, there was insistence on relocating the residents of this strip to the Sinai Peninsula in Egypt. Although Gaza has been sufficiently destroyed, and its reconstruction will take years, at least its inhabitants did not go elsewhere and still hope for a sustainable life in this strip. Now that the aforementioned goal has not been achieved, Gallant, as the Minister of War, has realized the necessity of how Gaza should be managed by a force other than Hamas and Israel. Gallant knows that the long-term presence of Israeli military personnel in Gaza is troublesome and therefore emphasizes that both military and non-military management of this strip by his country would incur heavy economic costs. For example, in 1978, Israel occupied the southern part of Lebanon with an attack. Later, in 1982, it advanced to the heart of Beirut. However, it retreated from Beirut but stayed in southern Lebanon until it was forced to withdraw. The result of that attack was the emergence of Hezbollah, street clashes, the erosion of war, and its consolidation in Lebanon. Gallant fears that the same scenario may repeat itself in the Gaza Strip.

2- As mentioned above, Netanyahu’s goal of turning Gaza into an uninhabitable area and dispersing its residents to the Sinai Peninsula in Egypt has not been achieved. The fact that he still does not entrust the management of Gaza to a non-Israeli force is due to two factors: firstly, he wants to once again render efforts to establish an independent Palestinian state futile. He has repeatedly stated that he will never consent to the establishment of a Palestinian state. Right-wing parties also strongly support his position. For example, Smotrich, Netanyahu’s right-wing Finance Minister, in response to Gallant’s request, said, “He declares support for the formation of a Palestinian state as a reward to Hamas with these statements.” Secondly, he wants the military capability of Hamas to be destroyed so that it is no longer a political and military force among Palestinians. According to Netanyahu, the prerequisite for achieving the aforementioned two goals is the retention of the Israeli army in the Gaza Strip. Of course, Israel was present in Gaza between 1967-2005, but Hamas did not have the current power. The reason Netanyahu does not trust self-governing bodies is explained in the introduction.

3- The option of dismissing Gallant could also be on Netanyahu’s table, but it’s not as simple as it seems. While Netanyahu’s United Right allies have called for Gallant’s dismissal or resignation, implementing it is challenging. Smotrich stated that Gallant must choose between resignation and the cabinet’s policies. Meanwhile, Itamar Ben-Gvir, the Minister of National Security of Israel, said that achieving the war’s objectives necessitates Gallant’s dismissal. However, Benny Gantz, a member of the war cabinet, defended Gallant, stating, “Gallant has spoken the truth, and the country’s leadership must take the right actions at any cost.” Perhaps in Gantz’s view, the goal of “taking the right action” is entrusting the management of Gaza to the Fatah movement, even at the risk of Hamas’ reconstruction. Gantz then announced his resignation from the war cabinet if the issue of how to manage Gaza is not addressed, during a press conference. However, Gallant, a prominent member of the Likud party and a well-known figure in Israeli politics, has his supporters. In the spring of the last year, when protests against Netanyahu’s judicial reform plan intensified, Gallant called for attention to the protesters’ demands and the cessation of that plan—a move that led to his dismissal from the Ministry of Defense in March of the same year. Gallant’s dismissal added to the volume of protests, and Netanyahu was forced to retain him. Now that Netanyahu’s government is in a more difficult situation than before, he will not accept the risk of dismissing Gallant.

4- Gallant’s desire aligns with that of the United States. White House officials have repeatedly reported their opposition to Israel’s reoccupation of Gaza. Just recently, Antony Blinken, the US Secretary of State, reiterated that his country opposes the reoccupation of Gaza. At the same time, he stated that they are not supporters of the Hamas government. Gallant was a guest at the White House for a few days in March of this year. He was likely persuaded there. The Biden administration may consent to create a rift in the Israeli war cabinet to restrain Netanyahu, as on the one hand, it may keep Rafah safe from the danger of a widespread ground attack, and on the other hand, it may lead to the adoption of a plan for managing Gaza. If this assumption is incorrect, it will be difficult for Gallant to build an opposition bloc against Netanyahu in conditions where his country is presumed to be at risk.


You can read the Persian version of this analysis article here:

جنگ غزه؛ دعوای رییس و وزیر بر سر چیست؟

ShareTweetSendSendShare

Related Posts

A composite image shows three men in front of a Middle East map with smoke and ships near Iran, amid fears of renewed war. (Photo Credit: Social Media)
Analysis

Middle East at a Crossroads: War or Negotiations?

10 November 2026 [t_time:1794300650]
A collage of four men speaking and listening at separate events as Israel’s coalition talks remain uncertain after the election. (Photo credit: Social media)
Analysis

Israel’s Election Leaves Path to a Coalition Government Unclear

31 October 2026 [t_time:1793444303]
Pro-Palestinian protesters hold Palestinian flags and signs calling Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu a "war criminal" during a demonstration in Washington, D.C. (Photo: Reuters)
World News

Protesters in Washington Demand Netanyahu’s Arrest

29 July 2026 [t_time:1785317745]

Latest

Loading latest news...

Popular stories

  • A scanned copy of the Taliban order outlining new restrictions requiring female doctors to have a mahram when working with male colleagues. (Photo credit: 8am.media)

    Taliban Order Female Doctors to Have Male Guardians to Work With Male Colleagues

    Share
    Share Tweet
  • Araghchi Warns: US Must Choose Between Accepting Iran’s Proposal and Continuing the War

    Share
    Share Tweet
  • ISIS-Khorasan: A Real Threat to the People of Afghanistan and a Political Opportunity for the Taliban

    Share
    Share Tweet
  • UN Report Reveals Shifts in Family Attitudes and Rise in Domestic Violence in Afghanistan

    Share
    Share Tweet
  • Taiwan Accuses China of Escalating Military Activities in the Western Pacific

    Share
    Share Tweet

Podcast

Insights
Insights

Join Lynne O’Donnell for 8AM’s podcast series, Insights.
Lynne talks with generals, diplomats, soldiers, journalists, politicians, activists, people who have front row seats for conflicts around the world, and citizens with a story to tell, happy or sad. For this first series, Afghanistan is the focus. Lynne and her guests talk about the collapse of the republic in August, 2021, and the impact since — for the people of Afghanistan, for the security of the region, for the safety of the world. It’s important, interesting and insightful.

Insights/22: Controlling the Narrative with Mina Sharif
byinsights8am

Controlling the Narrative

Lynne O’Donnell talks with Mina Sharif, author, activist, women’s rights campaigner, educator and mentor. They discuss who controls the narrative and who speaks for Afghanistan’s people when the Taliban appear to have seized control not only of the country but of the message, too.

Have a listen

Insights/22: Controlling the Narrative with Mina Sharif
Episode play icon
Insights/22: Controlling the Narrative with Mina Sharif
Episode Description
Episode play icon
Insights/21: Media Meltdown with Zahra Joya
Episode Description
Episode play icon
Insights/20: Terror Inc with Scott Richards
Episode Description
Episode play icon
Insights/19: Busting Stereotypes with Bushra Gohar
Episode Description
Episode play icon
Insights/18: Media Matters with Waliullah Rahmani
Episode Description
Episode play icon
Insights/17: What Goes Around Comes Around with Sima Samar
Episode Description
Search Results placeholder
Hasht-e Subh

8AM Media, also known as Hasht-e-Subh Daily, stands as Afghanistan's premier independent and non-profit newspaper, resonating as a beacon of journalistic integrity since its establishment in June 2007 by esteemed Afghan journalists and human rights advocates. With a steadfast commitment to citizen journalism and civic education, Hasht-e-Subh Daily has earned its place as the most esteemed publication in the nation.

Publisher: Sanjar Sohail
Email: [email protected]
Executive Director: Parwiz Kawa
Email: [email protected]

Read More

From America’s Exit to Russia’s Return: What Is Moscow Planning for Afghanistan?

Five Years Into Taliban Rule, Filmmakers in Afghanistan Battle Poverty and Unemployment

Kandahar Pomegranate Growers Fear Price Collapse as Taliban’s Export Promises Ring Hollow

WHO Calls for Resumption of House-to-House Polio Vaccination in Afghanistan

Irish Police Discover Explosive Device Near World Leaders’ Summit

Editor’s Choice

Every Saturday morning, 8AM MEDIA English Services Department will guide you through the week’s biggest stories from Afghanistan and the international community.

Subscribe

© 2026 - ©Hasht-e Subh Daily

No Result
View All Result
8am.Media
پښتو ویب‌پاڼه
ویب‌سایت فارسی
اۉزبېکچه ویب‌سایت
  • Home
  • News
    • Afghanistan News
    • World News
  • Opinion
    • Editorial
    • Analysis
  • Reports
    • Daily Reports
    • Investigative Reports
  • Society
    • The story of people
  • Women’s Word
  • Columns
    • Three Years After Afghanistan’s Fall: The Taliban’s Resurgence
    • Towards Equality
    • The Resurgence of the Taliban: Two Years Since Afghanistan’s Fall
    • Hebatullah Report Special Edition
    • Resistance for Education Special Edition
    • Special Column on Taliban’s Education Curriculum
    • Nawroz
  • Interviews
  • Contact Us
    • About Us
    • 8AM MEDIA Annual Awards
    • Submit an Article to Hasht-e-Subh
  • 8am.media

© 2026 - ©Hasht-e Subh Daily